We have a brand new updated website! Click here to check it out!

Education Frontlines: The Anti-Testing Movement

John Richard Schrock

By JOHN RICHARD SCHROCK

Despite the public outrage over rich parents buying their children admission into elite colleges, the educationist community is rising up against the use of universal external tests There are only two useful and relatively objective measures of student academic potential and both of them rely on tests.

So why is America going schizophrenic, protesting rich parents buying their kids into elite schools on one hand, while condemning the use of academic testing on the other?

Much anti-test fever appears to be a long overdue disappointment with nearly two decades of  external state assessment testing extorted by No Child Left Behind. External testing still remains in its ESSA reincarnation. Two generations of students have burned out from uninspired teaching-to-the-test and the education community is now ready to move to other interventions. “State assessment tests may be bad” is now being openly discussed in education newspapers and blogs.

Consider how this last two decades would have played out if we had tried to improve our medical services by standardized testing. Some folks are dying so we decide to give uniform tests to everyone and hold doctors accountable for raising survival. We can’t test everything so we focus on temperature and pain, believing medicine can only be improved by universal testing. While fever and pain are the important indicators, they are only part of the health picture. Doctors could no longer make their own decision on a variety of tests for a variety of patients. Just as we lost art and music teachers because only language arts and math are tested, so we would see a shift to practicing medicine to these narrow external test. Since the high stakes of a hospital’s ratings and a doctor’s job would depend on it, every patient gets a heavy dose of aspirin so they all exit smiling. Scores go up, but actual health goes down.

This is precisely what has happened to our students. By teaching-to-the-prior achievement testing, scores have gone up. But valid measures of aptitude such as the NAEP, ACT and SAT have gone down. Sadly, after two decades, teacher training programs across the country have often eliminated coursework in “tests and measurement” because teachers are no longer expected to write their own tests, customized to their student population. But it was the professional judgement of medical doctors that determined what unique tests are used for unique students, and it is no different for teachers.        

Professional contempt for external state assessments is long overdue. Indeed some states moved to use the ACT or SAT in place of state assessments. These are not content-specific achievement tests that are easy to teach-to. As aptitude tests that evaluate a student’s general ability to handle new intellectual material. They do not intrude into the teacher’s classroom and force teachers to teach-to-the-test. The innocent aptitude test baby should not be thrown out with the dirty achievement test bathwater.

However, by far the best predictor of college success remains the high school grade point average (GPA). Historically, high school GPA reflected a wide array of abilities, such as showing up on time, study ethic, ability to focus and pay attention, etc. in addition to content knowledge. As long as the individual teacher can re-assert their professionalism and not suffer interference from administrators who insist every student passes, or that the teacher’s internal test be aligned with some external test, the high school GPA can remain a good predictor of college ability. Unfortunately, the same external pressures that were exerted on raising scores on the state assessments are being used to constrain many teachers from flunking failing students and are forcing grade inflation and higher levels of high school graduation.

Unfortunately, all testing is now being portrayed as bad. At this year’s American Educational Research Association meeting, the AERA President, a professor at the Columbia University Teachers College, spoke on how testing is being used to perpetuate a separate and unequal education system for disadvantaged students. This is equivalent to stating that underserved students are not getting as good  medical treatment due to standardized medical exams, so all medical exams are bad.

But if we return to internal teacher-written tests for unique students, then we can return to “healthier” and more professional schools. –And reserve just one external aptitude test for fairer entrance to colleges.  


John Richard Schrock has trained biology teachers for more than 30 years in Kansas. He also has lectured at 27 universities in 20 trips to China. He holds the distinction of “Faculty Emeritus” at Emporia State University.                

Copyright Eagle Radio | FCC Public Files | EEO Public File